Ganymede & Titan

G&T Spoiler Policy

User login

Who's online

There are currently 2 users and 8 guests online.

Syndicate

RSS Feed  Livejournal  Feed Dwarfcasts RSS Feed  iTunes Feed

Recommendations

“spoiled by the usual four-lettered garbage that seems to spout from the usual suspects mouth” - Liam, Official Webboard

John Hoare / 10.01.06 / 4:39 am

Cop-out?

Now, as you all know, I love Meltdown. But there’s one bit that’s always slightly bothered me:

KRYTEN: He’s been acting strangely ever since we landed here, sir. I think it might have affected his mind when you chewed his light bee.
LISTER: I’ll do more than chew his light bee when we get out of here.

Was this added because Rob and Doug thought Rimmer was acting a bit too out-of-character? I can’t see any other reason for its inclusion - but it’s just not needed. Yeah, Rimmer is acting to extremes, but then it’s an extreme situation. I think it’s perfectly plausible how he reacts. The hints are there - his admiration for Napoleon, his Fascist Dictators Monthly, his chat about war in Marooned. Unlike Holly’s ion storm, I think it’s perfectly in-character.

As it is, it smacks of cop-out in the writing, which is a shame. Unless I’m just misinterpreting it…

Comments